Available 24/7 · We Proudly Serve Clients in Southeastern Pennsylvania, Including Bensalem & Allentown
Applebaum Joachim Law Group logo
Applebaum Joachim Law Group logo
215-440-6285

Your Ex Won't Follow Your Holiday Custody Order in PA. What Can You Do?

Your Ex Won't Follow Your Holiday Custody Order in PA. What Can You Do.jpgYour Ex Won't Follow Your Holiday Custody Order in PA. What Can You Do.jpg

The holidays are approaching, and you've been looking forward to spending time with your child. Your custody order sets out when your child will be with you, but now your ex says they're changing the plans.

Maybe they're refusing to bring your child to Thanksgiving dinner. Maybe they've decided your child will spend Christmas with them, even though the court order says otherwise.

You're left wondering whether they can do that and what you can do to protect your parenting time.

In Pennsylvania, a parent generally cannot disregard a court-ordered custody schedule simply because they prefer different holiday arrangements. If your ex refuses to follow the order, you have legal options to address the dispute and protect your parenting time.

Understanding how Pennsylvania courts handle these disputes can help you decide what steps to take before your scheduled holiday parenting time is affected.

Does Your Pennsylvania Custody Order Apply During the Holidays?

Yes. A Pennsylvania custody order remains enforceable during Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's, and other holidays.

Many custody orders include specific holiday schedules that differ from regular weekly parenting arrangements. For example, one parent might have Thanksgiving in even-numbered years and Christmas Day in odd-numbered years.

When the order establishes a separate holiday schedule, those provisions generally control during the designated periods.

Before assuming your ex has violated the order, review its exact language. Look for provisions addressing:

  • Which parent has custody on each holiday.
  • When holiday parenting time begins and ends.
  • Where and how custody exchanges must occur.
  • Whether holiday arrangements take priority over the regular schedule.

If the order is unclear or does not specifically address a particular holiday, determining which schedule applies can become more complicated.

The distinction matters because a disagreement over an ambiguous provision is not necessarily the same as deliberately violating a clear court order.

What Should You Do if Your Ex Refuses to Follow the Holiday Custody Order?

If your ex tells you they're keeping your child for Thanksgiving or changing the Christmas schedule without your agreement, start by checking what your custody order actually requires.

If the holiday arrangements are clearly spelled out, consider reminding the other parent of the scheduled exchange time and the relevant provision.

When communication is possible and safe, put your concerns in writing. For example, you can refer to the order, confirm when you're supposed to pick up your child, and ask whether your ex intends to follow the arrangement.

This creates a record of your efforts to resolve the disagreement without escalating the situation.

Avoid making threats, arguing through repeated messages, or involving your child in the disagreement.

A parent's refusal to cooperate does not change the custody order. The existing order remains enforceable unless the court changes it.

If your ex continues refusing to comply, the next question is whether their conduct warrants court intervention.

Can You File for Contempt if Your Ex Violates a Custody Order in PA?

Yes. If your ex willfully violates your custody order, Pennsylvania law allows you to ask the court to hold them in contempt.

Under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5323(g), a parent who willfully fails to comply with a custody order can face court-imposed sanctions.

There is an important distinction between threatening to violate the order and actually failing to comply with it. If your ex has announced plans to withhold your child but the scheduled exchange has not occurred, an attorney can assess whether another form of court intervention is appropriate before the holiday.

The court considers whether the order was clear, whether the parent failed to comply, and whether the circumstances establish willful disobedience rather than an inability to follow the order.

For example, deliberately refusing to return a child at the court-ordered time presents different circumstances from an exchange delayed by an unexpected medical emergency.

To pursue contempt, a parent generally files a petition with the appropriate court describing the alleged violation.

Under Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1915.12, the petition must identify the facts supporting the allegation of willful noncompliance and include a copy of the custody order.

The other parent receives notice and an opportunity to appear before the court.

What Can a Pennsylvania Court Do About a Custody Violation?

When a court finds that a parent willfully violated a custody order, Pennsylvania law authorizes several possible sanctions.

Depending on the circumstances, these include fines, counsel fees and costs, probation, and, in certain cases, imprisonment.

These consequences are not automatic. The court must consider the applicable legal requirements before imposing a sanction.

A contempt proceeding also does not automatically change which parent has custody or guarantee replacement parenting time.

If ongoing problems suggest that the current arrangement is no longer workable, a parent can separately seek modification of the custody order.

Under 23 Pa.C.S. § 5338, Pennsylvania courts can modify custody orders when doing so serves the child's best interests.

At Applebaum Joachim Law Group, we understand that these disputes involve more than disagreements between parents. They can affect your child's stability, family traditions, and ability to maintain meaningful relationships with both parents.

What Evidence Should You Keep if Your Ex Violates the Order?

If a holiday custody dispute reaches court, documentation can help establish what happened.

Consider preserving:

  • Your current custody order: Keep a complete copy, including any amendments.
  • Text messages and emails: Save communications about holiday arrangements, cancellations, and refusals to cooperate.
  • Exchange details: Record the dates, times, and locations of missed or delayed exchanges.
  • Other supporting records: Save relevant travel arrangements, exchange-location details, or other records that help establish what happened.

Keep your records factual and organized rather than relying on memory after the holiday has passed.

Also, avoid withholding your child during your ex's scheduled parenting time in retaliation. Taking matters into your own hands can create additional custody problems.

If your child faces an immediate safety threat, that is different from an ordinary scheduling disagreement and requires prompt attention through appropriate emergency or legal channels.

Can You Get Court Help Before a Holiday Custody Violation Happens?

If Thanksgiving or Christmas is approaching and your ex has already said they won't follow the custody order, you don't necessarily have to wait until the scheduled exchange is missed to seek legal guidance.

Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1915.13 allows courts to grant appropriate interim or special relief in custody proceedings. Depending on the circumstances and the court's procedures, an attorney can assess whether requesting special relief or another form of intervention before the holiday is appropriate.

For example, if your custody order clearly gives you Christmas morning with your child but the other parent has announced they won't allow the exchange, the timing and terms of the existing order become especially important.

That does not mean the court will resolve the dispute before the holiday. Hearing availability, filing requirements, and the nature of the disagreement all affect how quickly the matter can be addressed.

Seeking guidance promptly gives you an opportunity to understand your options before the dispute disrupts your scheduled parenting time.

Facing a Holiday Custody Dispute in Pennsylvania? Understand Your Options

The holidays should be an opportunity to spend meaningful time with your child, not another source of uncertainty about whether your custody arrangement will be honored.

If your ex refuses to follow your court-ordered holiday schedule, understanding your rights and the available enforcement procedures can help you make informed decisions.

At Applebaum Joachim Law Group, we help parents navigate child custody disputes with straightforward guidance and attention to their family's circumstances. From our Bensalem and Allentown offices, we serve families throughout Bucks County, Montgomery County, Lehigh County, Northampton County, and surrounding communities.

If you're dealing with a holiday custody disagreement, contact our firm to discuss your situation and learn what legal options may be available.

Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every custody matter depends on its specific facts and circumstances.